| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity DisorderHighlightsPending Drug Approval At the time of this report, the FDA was considering approving a methylphenidate skin patch (Daytrana) for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Methylphenidate is the same drug used in Ritalin and other psychostimulants. The patch is designed for children who cannot take pills. Drug Safety
Quality of Life
IntroductionAccording to the U.S. National Institutes of Mental Health, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a legitimate psychologic condition. ADHD is a syndrome generally characterized by the following symptoms:
Some experts categorize ADHD into three subtypes:
There is some debate over these criteria. Some argue the condition is over-diagnosed. Others say it's underdiagnosed. (See Difficulties in Identifying Children with ADHD later in this article.) One-third of cases is accompanied by learning disabilities and other neurologic or emotional problems, making an ADHD diagnosis particularly difficult. It is likely that the term attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder will eventually give way to subgroups of problems that include some of these general symptoms. General Description of a Child with ADHDSymptoms of ADHD usually occur before the age of seven. Studies indicate that ADHD symptoms in preschool children with ADHD do not differ significantly from older children. The classic ADHD symptoms do not always adequately describe the child's behavior, nor do they describe what is actually happening in the child's mind. Some experts are focusing on deficits in "executive functions" of the brain to understand and describe all ADHD behaviors. Such impaired executive functions in ADHD children can cause the following problems:
Hyperactivity. The term hyperactive is often confusing since, for some, it suggests a child racing around non-stop. A boy with ADHD playing a game, for instance, may have the same level of activity as another child without the syndrome. But when a high demand is placed on the ADHD child's attention, his brain motor activity intensifies beyond the levels of the other children. In a busy environment, such as a classroom or a crowded store, ADHD children often become distracted and react by pulling items off the shelves, hitting people, or spinning out of control into erratic, silly, or strange behavior. Impulsivity and Temper Explosions. Even before the "terrible two's," impulsive behavior is often apparent. The toddler may gleefully make erratic and aggressive gestures, such as hair pulling, pinching, and hitting. Temper tantrums, normal in children after two, are usually exaggerated and not necessarily linked to a specific negative event in the life of an ADHD child. One of the most painful events a parent may experience is an abrupt and aggressive attack that may occur after cuddling a young ADHD child. Often this reaction seems to be caused not by anger, but by the child's apparent inability to endure overstimulation or displays of physical affection. Attention and Concentration. ADHD children are usually distracted and made inattentive by an overstimulating environment (such as a large classroom). They are also inattentive when a situation is low-key or dull. Some experts believe that certain parts of the brain in ADHD children may be underactive, so the children fail to be aroused by nonstimulating activities. In contrast, they may exhibit a kind of "super concentration" to a highly stimulating activity (such as a video game or a highly specific interest). Such children may even become over-attentive -- so absorbed in a project that they cannot modify or change the direction of their attention. Impaired Short-Term Memory. Many experts now believe that an essential feature in ADHD, as well as in learning disabilities, is an impaired working (also called short-term) memory. People with ADHD can't hold groups of sentences and images in their mind long enough to extract organized thoughts. They are not necessarily inattentive. Instead, an ADHA patient may be unable to remember a full explanation (such as a homework assignment), or unable to complete processes that require remembering sequences, such as model building. In general, children with ADHD are often attracted to activities (e.g., television, computer games, or active individual sports) that do not tax the working memory, or produce distractions. Children with ADHD have no differences in long-term memory compared with other children. Inability to Manage Time. Studies suggest that children with ADHD have difficulties being on time and planning the correct amount of time to complete tasks. (This may coincide with short-term memory problems.) In one study, although children with probable ADHD were able to self-report many ADHD symptoms, they tended to believe they used their time wisely, in contrast to reports by their teacher. Lack of Adaptability. ADHD children have a very difficult time adapting to even minor changes in routines, such as getting up in the morning, putting on shoes, eating new foods, or going to bed. Any shift in a situation can precipitate a strong and noisy negative response. Even when they are in a good mood, they may suddenly shift into a tantrum if met with an unexpected change or frustration. In one experiment, ADHD children could closely focus their attention when directly cued to a specific location, but they had difficulty shifting their attention to an alternative location. Hypersensitivity and Sleep Problems. ADHD children are often hypersensitive to sights, sounds, and touch. They usually complain excessively about stimuli that seem low key or bland to others. Sleeping problems usually occur well after the point when most small children sleep through the night. In one study, 63% of children with ADHD had trouble sleeping.
Risk FactorsIn the U.S., the diagnosis of ADHD in children increased from 1990 to 1996, from nearly 950,000 to over 2,400,000 cases. The prevalence of ADHD ranges from 2 - 18% of the population, depending on where and how the studies were conducted. ADHD is a genuine disorder, but it should be strongly noted that the U.S. accounts for 90% of worldwide prescriptions for stimulants for ADHD. It is not known whether this reflects a real increase in ADHD, or a better ability to recognize it. Some say it may be an indication of a culture that places excessive value on normalcy and academic achievement at the expense of more frequent diagnoses. Gender and ADHDADHD is most often diagnosed in boys. However, there is some evidence that it is underdiagnosed in girls. Until recently, all major studies were conducted using boys as subjects. Important studies on girls with ADHD are now underway. A major study is reporting that girls with the condition experience the same multiple impairments as boys do. Adults with ADHDAlthough ADHD is primarily thought of as a childhood disorder, diagnoses of attention-deficit disorder in adults are on the rise. Methylphenidate (Ritalin) was prescribed for nearly 800,000 adults in the U.S. in 1997, nearly three times the number in 1992.
CausesBrain Structures. Increasingly, research using advanced imaging techniques shows there is a difference in the size of certain parts of the brain of ADHD children compared to children who do not have ADHD. The areas showing change include:
It is important to note that such abnormalities do not get worse and are unrelated to intelligence. Brain Chemicals. Abnormal activity of certain brain chemicals in the prefrontal cortex may contribute to ADHD. The chemicals dopamine and norepinephrine are of special interest. Dopamine and norepinephrine are neurotransmitters, or chemical messengers, that affect both mental and emotional functioning. They also play a role in the "reward response." This response occurs when a person experiences pleasure in response to certain stimuli (such as food or love). Studies now suggest that increased levels of the brain chemicals glutamate, glutamine, and GABA, collectively called Glx, interact with the pathways that transport dopamine and norepinephrine. Nerve Pathways. Another area of interest is a network of nerves called the basal-ganglia thalamocortical pathways. Abnormalities along this neural route have been associated with ADHD, Tourette's syndrome, and obsessive-compulsive disorders, which all share certain symptoms. Genetic FactorsGenetic factors may play the most important role in ADHD. The relatives of ADHD children (both boys and girls) have much higher rates of ADHD, antisocial, mood, anxiety, and substance abuse disorders than the families of non-ADHD children. A study reported that 90% of children with a diagnosis of ADHD shared it with their twin. Genetic Factors Regulating Dopamine and Advantages in Early Man. Most of the research on the underlying genetic mechanisms targets the neurotransmitter dopamine. Variations in genes that regulate specific dopamine receptors have been identified in a high proportion of people with addictions and ADHD. Such genes have been associated with novelty seeking and extroversion. Some experts theorize that the genetic variants may have first appeared thousands of years ago, and affect as many as half of ADHD children. Furthermore, the genetic variations may have offered some benefits to their early carriers. In such people, a genetic predilection for novelty-seeking and risk-taking may have supplied an advantage in reproduction, mating, hunting, and achieving dominance. Genetic Resistance to Thyroid Hormone. About 50% of adults and 70% of children with a genetic resistance to thyroid hormone, essential for normal brain development, have ADHD. People who have this condition appear to have a more severe form of ADHD. The thyroid disorder is not a common cause of ADHD. Only those with a family history of thyroid disease are at risk. Pregnancy and ADHDADHD is often associated with problem pregnancies and difficult deliveries. If a women smokes during pregnancy, a genetically susceptible child is at higher risk for ADHD. One study indicated that an increased risk also existed in children of women who were exposed during pregnancy to environmental toxins, including dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Dietary FactorsInfant malnutrition is a strong risk factor of ADHD. Even if children receive enough food later on, infants who suffer from malnutrition may develop behavior problems, the most prevalent being attention-deficit disorder. A number of dietary factors have been researched in assocation with ADHD, including sensitivities to certain food chemicals, deficiencies in fatty acids and zinc, and sensitivity to sugar. No clear evidence has emerged that implicates any of these nutritional factors in ADHD. Deficiencies in Zinc and Essential Fatty Acids. Some studies have found an association between deficiencies in certain fatty acids (compounds that make up fats and oils) and ADHD. Other research reports an association between zinc deficiencies and ADHD. Zinc aids in the breakdown of fatty acids, which affects dopamine, the neurotransmitter likely to be involved with ADHD. DiagnosisThe American Academy of Pediatrics issued its first guidelines for diagnosing attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children in 2002. They include the following:
Difficulties in Identifying Children with ADHDThere are currently no laboratory or imaging tests to reliably diagnose ADHD. A diagnosis relies only on behavioral symptoms and ruling out other disorders. Many experts believe that the disorder is both over- and underdiagnosed. Diagnosis of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder is difficult for some of the following reasons: Arguments that ADHD is Overdiagnosed in Some Children.
Arguments that ADHD is Underdiagnosed in Some Children.
History of BehaviorThe doctor will first require a detailed history of the child's behavior. Doctors will match this against a standardized checklist to define the disorder. The parents should describe the following:
The health professional will want to know how the parents handle different situations, and may want to observe them interacting with the child. Physical ExaminationThe child should also be given a general physical examination to determine if any medical conditions are present. The child should be given a hearing test to rule out hearing abnormalities as a source of behavioral problems. Screening TestsContinuous Performance Test. A test called the Continuous Performance Test is sometimes helpful in evaluating sustained attention and impulsivity. The child sits in front of a computer screen and is asked to press or not press certain keys in response to images on the screen. Other Screening Tests. Other tests are available to test neurologic, intellectual, and emotional development problems. Most involve learning and problem solving tasks that help define the particular areas that are most disabling. Blood or other laboratory tests are currently recommended only if the doctor suspects lead toxicity or other medical problems. Investigative Objective TestsOptical Tracking and Attention Test. OPTax (optical tracking and attention test) uses two approaches:
Such a test offers a possible simple and objective way to determine a diagnosis. QEEG Test. The quantitative electroencephalographic procedure (QEEG) assesses the electrical activity in a part of the brain called the prefrontal cortex. Evidence suggests that ADHD is associated with low activity in this region. Studies are reporting that it may be highly accurate in both diagnosing and ruling out ADHD in patients. Imaging Techniques. Brain scans using imaging techniques, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) may eventually help confirm a diagnosis. At this time, however, they are used only for research. Drug TrialsAlthough it is fairly common to use a trial of a psychostimulant (usually Ritalin) to facilitate diagnosis, experts strongly recommend against this method of diagnosis, because it is not always accurate. An improvement in symptoms is considered suggestive of ADHD, while in non-ADHD children the stimulant often increases agitation and hyperactivity. Many children and adults without the disorder have a similar response, and such a diagnostic trial may lead to unnecessary prescriptions of this drug. Other Disorders Associated with ADHDA number of disorders may mimic or accompany attention-deficit disorder. ADHD exists alone in only about one-third of children. Many professionals object to the use of the single term “attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder” to encompass such a wide spectrum of behaviors, which they believe should be categorized into subgroups. Many of these problems require other modes of treatment and should be diagnosed separately, even if they accompany ADHD. Attention-Deficit Disorder without HyperactivityAttention-deficit disorder can appear without hyperactivity, in which case the child's primary symptoms are distractibility and an inability to persist in tasks. Oppositional-Defiant DisorderAbout 35% of children diagnosed with ADHD also have oppositional-defiant disorder (ODD). The most common symptom for this disorder is a pattern of negative, defiant, and hostile behavior toward authority figures that lasts more than 6 months. In addition to displaying inattentive and impulsive behavior, these children demonstrate aggression, have frequent temper tantrums, and display antisocial behavior. Up to 25% of children with ODD have phobias and other anxiety disorders, which should be treated separately. Conduct DisorderSome children with ADHD also have conduct disorder, which describes a complex group of behavioral and emotional disturbances seen in children. It includes aggression towards people and animals, destruction of property, deceitfulness, lying, or stealing, and general violation of rules. Pervasive Developmental DisorderPervasive developmental disorder (PDD) is rare and usually marked by autistic-type behavior, hand-flapping, repetitive statements, slow social development, and speech and motor problems. If a child who has been diagnosed with ADHD does not respond to treatment, the parents might inquire about PDD, which often responds to antidepressants. Preliminary research also suggests that children with PDD may benefit from stimulants such as methylphenidate (Ritalin, Concerta). A 2005 study reported that methylphenidate worked better than placebo in treating hyperactivity in children with PDD. However, these children did not respond as well to methylphenidate as children with ADHD. The drug also caused side effects in many of the children with PDD. Primary Disorder of VigilancePrimary disorder of vigilance is a term for a syndrome that includes poor attention and concentration as well as difficulties staying awake. The term is not recognized as an official diagnosis by the American Psychiatric Association, but some experts believe it represents a fairly well defined set of behaviors. People with vigilance disorder tend to fidget, yawn and stretch, and appear to be hyperactive in order to remain alert; they typically have kind and affectionate temperaments. The condition appears to be inherited and gets worse with age. It it is treatable with stimulants. Central Auditory Processing Disorder and Hearing ProblemsChildren with ADHD often have difficulties with tasks that involve listening or hearing. Research is indicating that symptoms of the two disorders often overlap but may actually be two distinct disorders. Hearing problems themselves may cause ADHD symptoms. Bipolar Disorder (Manic Depression)One study found that as many as 25% of children diagnosed with attention-deficit disorder may also have bipolar disorder, commonly called manic depression. Indications of this problem include episodes of depression and mania (with symptoms of irritability, rapid speech, and disconnected thoughts), sometimes occurring at the same time. [See In-Depth Report #66: Bipolar Disorder.] Both disorders often cause inattention and distractibility and may be difficult to distinguish, particularly in children. Children with mania and ADHD may have more aggression, behavioral problems, and emotional disorders than those with ADHD alone. In some cases, ADHD in children or adolescents can even be a marker for an emerging bipolar disorder. The primary way to differentiate bipolar disorder from ADHD is by the presence of a manic or hypomanic episode, which occurs in patients with bipolar disorder but not with ADHD. Most children with bipolar will also respond to the drug valproate, which does not typically work for ADHD in children. Anxiety DisordersAnxiety disorders commonly accompany ADHD. Obsessive-compulsive disorder is a specific anxiety disorder that shares many characteristics with ADHD and may share a genetic component. Young children who have experienced traumatic events, including sexual or physical abuse or neglect, exhibit characteristics of ADHD, including impulsivity, emotional outbursts, and oppositional behavior. Sleep DisordersSleep disorders or disturbances are very common with ADHD patients. Insomnia is common. In addition, specific sleep disorders--restless legs syndrome and sleep-disordered breathing--have been identified with hyperactivity and conduct disorder. Restless Legs Syndrome (RLS). Some experts believe RLS and periodic limb movement disorder are strongly associated with ADHD in some children. One theory is that the two are linked by a common mechanism. The disorders have much in common, including poor sleep habits, twitching, and the need to get up suddenly and walk about frequently. They may even be genetically linked. For example, both have been associated with lower levels of dopamine in the brain, which is associated with faulty motor control, a common problem in both disorders. Sleep-Disorder Breathing and Sleep Apnea. Some research has shown an association between mild symptoms of ADHD and sleep-disordered breathing, including snoring and obstructive sleep apnea in children and adults. Treating the sleep-related breathing disorders may improve the attention disorder in some children. (One study indicated that such problems are unlikely to be associated with children with moderate to severe ADHD.) [See In-Depth Report #65: Sleep Apnea.] Other DiagnosesTourette's Syndrome and Other Genetic Disorders. A number of genetic disorders cause symptoms resembling ADHD, including fragile X and Tourette's syndrome. About 50% of those with Tourette's syndrome also have ADHD and some of the treatments are similar. Other Medical Conditions. A number of medical conditions, including hyperthyroidism and vision problems, can produce ADHD-like symptoms. Lead. Children who ingest even low amounts of lead may manifest symptoms similar to those of ADHD. A child may be easily distractible, disorganized, and have trouble thinking logically. The major cause of lead toxicity is exposure to leaded paint, particularly in homes that are old and in poor repair. ComplicationsEmotional DisordersMore than half of children with attention-deficit disorder have accompanying disorders, including anxiety, depression, and conduct disorders. Children with ADHD who experience anxiety or depression are also more likely to suffer from low self-esteem. One study found that 25% of children with ADHD have or develop bipolar disorder (commonly called manic depression). Social ProblemsAnti-Social Behavior. Even if these emotional disorders are absent in childhood, the ADHD child's relationship with others is volatile, and he or she is often unhappy from a very young age. Research indicates that any ADHD boy or girl, particularly an aggressive child, has trouble getting along with others, and is less liked by his or her peers.
Substance Abuse in Young People. Studies consistently report that ADHD young people--in particularly those with conduct or mood disorders--have a higher than average risk for substance abuse and that it starts in younger ages. In one study, for example, by age 11 nearly 20% of children with ADHD had tried smoking cigarettes, drinking alcohol, or both. Biologic factors associated with ADHD may make these individuals susceptible to substance abuse. Many of these young people are self-medicating their condition. In fact, according to a major analysis, Ritalin or other stimulants used to treat ADHD may help protect such patients against substance abuse. (Boys with ADHD and conduct disorder, however, still face a high risk for substance abuse. Girls with ADHD and emotional disorders may also still have a higher risk.) High-Risk Behavior. Impulsivity in ADHD young people can certainly cause them to take chances before thinking them through, putting them in situations where the consequences become clear only after the action has been taken. ADHD children with high levels of aggression are at higher risk for delinquent behavior in adolescents and criminal activity in adulthood. It should be strongly noted that ADHD children who are not aggressive have a lower and even normal risk for dangerous activities. Even in aggressive ADHD children, close parental attention and early treatment can limit the risk considerably. Learning ProblemsAlthough speech and learning disorders are common in children with ADHD, the disorder does not affect intelligence. People with ADHD span the same IQ range as the general population. One study suggested, however, that 90% of ADHD children were underachievers, and that half were held back at least once. Some evidence suggests that inattention may be a major factor in low academic performance in these children. About 20% also have reading difficulties and 60% have serious handwriting problems. Adults with ADHD are also at very high risk for these conditions. Persistence of ADHD into AdulthoodSome research suggests that ADHD persists in one- to two-thirds of those diagnosed with the condition in childhood. Many experts, in fact, describe the pattern of ADHD as they would a chronic illness, in terms of whether it goes into remission or not. They define this remission in three categories of severity:
In one study using these criteria, 60% of ADHD Caucasian boys were in syndromatic remission four years after the onset of the study, and 10% were fully recovered (in functional remission). Older individuals were more likely to retain symptoms of inattentiveness than those of impulsivity and hyperactivity. Because inattentiveness affects organizational skills, this could be a significant problem in adulthood. It should be noted, however, that the study lasted only 4 years and stopped between ages 18 and 20. The study did not include girls or boys in other ethnic groups, so it is not known if these results are generally applicable. Effect on FamilyThe time and attention needed to deal with the ADHD child can change internal family relationships and have devastating effects on parents and siblings. Effect on Parents. Studies increasingly suggest that any intervention for an ADHD child must include the parents. Parents who are responsive to their child in a positive way can help reduce the chances for oppositional behaviors. But it can be very difficult. The ADHD child is wonderful one day and terrible the next, for no apparent reason. The parent can feel betrayed and hurt, and believe they have no control over their child. Parents must protect themselves and their child by establishing tough but kind rules about where their space ends and the child's begins. The are many effects on parents:
Effect on Siblings. Siblings of ADHD children have particular difficulties, and are also at risk for psychologic impairment, depression, drug abuse, and language disorders. The non-ADHD sibling does not have the control a parent does in the management of the ADHD child's behavior and is very likely to feel alienated and alone. Non-ADHD children are often victimized by ADHD siblings who may be demanding or bullying. A sibling who is not given attention in his or her own right may begin to imitate undesirable behaviors or to act out negatively in other ways. It is very important to make the brothers and sisters equally vital to the family's functioning. It should be strongly emphasized, however, that their value in the family should never be as fellow-caregivers of the ADHD sibling. TreatmentA combination of a psychostimulant, most commonly methylphenidate (Ritalin), and cognitive-behavioral therapy is proving to be the best option for treatment of children with ADHD. In 1999, a large study compared medication, behavior therapy, a combination of both, and standard community care. While all four groups improved, medication, when carefully monitored, was more effective than behavior therapy alone, and its effects were similar to combination therapy. The combined approach, however, allowed lower doses of medication and also improved academic performance and family relations. In addition, it was more helpful for children who also had mood disorders (such as depression or anxiety) or oppositional-defiant disorder. A 2001 study further suggested that 80% of adolescents with ADHD who were treated with a combined approach showed an improvement in academic performance. Developing a Treatment Approach. The following guidelines may be useful in determining a treatment approach for children with ADHD:
Unfortunately, most children do not have access to behavioral therapies, either because of lack of time or available resources. A 2000 study reported that fewer than half of all doctor's visits involving a psychostimulant prescription included pschologic intervention. In addition, there was no follow-up at all after 21% of these visits. One study suggested that a simple 8-week program conducted in the primary care doctor's office may be of some help. Children in the study received either a combination of drugs with the program or drugs alone. They had no complicating problems, such as anxiety or conduct disorder. Children who received the combination approach showed improved functioning at home that persisted for at least 6 months, although teachers observed no differences in two groups. Specific Patient Populations. Unfortunately, such guidelines do not address the following specific patient groups:
Arguments For and Against Psychostimulants. Many parents are very disturbed by the idea of putting their children on intensive stimulant drug regimens, possibly for years, particularly given the uncertainties in diagnosis and the negative publicity surrounding the use of these drugs. Although the decision to use these drugs should not be made lightly, the negative social and emotional effects of the disorder itself for many children with ADHD are far more severe and long-lasting than the use of these drugs. For some parents and children, medication seems like a miracle and can provide desperate families with a quality of life for which they had almost given up hope. Still, there are a number of questions, particularly for taking psychostimulants alone without additional behavioral therapy. Of great concern is the dramatic increase in prescriptions for psychostimulants among preschool children, not only in the US but also in some European countries. There is evidence the drugs may be over-prescribed, and parents should discuss the question of medications very carefully with their doctors. ADHD represents a growing market for pharmaceutical companies. Although psychostimulants and alternative drugs are proving to be helpful for many families, no one should underestimate the influence of the economic issues involved. It should be noted that a major study reported that children with ADHD will benefit to some degree from any treatment, whether behavioral therapies, medication, or simple mental health intervention. Combinations of behavioral therapy and medications appear to be best, however. Stimulants are not a cure-all, and children should not grow up believing that taking a pill will solve life's problems without their having to make self-efforts. Help for Families and TeachersResearch increasingly supports the view that interventions for the ADHD child must also include the parents if they are to be successful. Teachers and school officials should also be educated and involved in the process. Parents who feel they have the most control over their child's situation also experience the least psychological stress and depression. Parents who are responsive in a positive way also help reduce the chances for their child developing oppositional behaviors. But it can be very difficult, particularly for parents who have ADHD themselves. In fact, parents who have severe ADHD symptoms are less likely to respond to parent training programs unless they get help for themselves. In addition to behavioral therapy for the child, family therapy may help ADHD children and their parents and siblings cope with the emotional conflicts that nearly always arise in the lifelong process of managing the condition. Separate psychological therapies for specific family members might be needed, particularly in light of the high incidence of psychiatric and other emotional problems in families with ADHD children.
MedicationsThere are an increasing number of medications available to treat ADHD. Pyschostimulants: Methylphenidate (Ritalin) and Similar DrugsPsychostimulants, to date, are the primary drugs used to treat ADHD. Methylphenidate (Ritalin, Metadate, Concerta) is the most commonly used psychostimulant for ADHD. Its positive benefits for improving ADHD symptoms appear to be due to its actions in increasing dopamine, a neurotransmitter important for motor control. This drug is effective in both children and adults. A similar drug dexmethylphenidate (Focalin) has been approved. It is similar to in methylphenidate in effectiveness and side effects. At the time of this report, the FDA was also considering approving a new skin patch for ADHD. The patch, Daytrana, delivers a 9-hour dose of methylphenidate. It is designed for children who cannot take pills. Regimen. The older form of Ritalin is short acting, and needs to be taken several times a day, including during school hours. As it wears off, a rebound effect can occur and ADHD symptoms intensify. Longer-acting forms (Concerta, Ritalin LA, Ritalin SR, Metadate) are now available. Concerta is now the most commonly prescribed drug for ADHD and uses a special pump action that releases the medication gradually into the body and can be effective for 12 hours. Ritalin LA and Metadate also only need to be taken once during the entire school day. (Ritalin SR can still can wear off by early afternoon.) A patch form of methylphenidate (MethylPatch) is awaiting approval. A 4-week trial in 2002 reported that it was very effective in improving attention and improving behavior. A 2003 study of Concerta indicated that depending on the ADHD subtype, children may require different doses. In the study, children with the inattentive type responded to lower doses than those with the combined type. Side Effects. All stimulants have a number of side effects:
Of note, taking Ritalin with a high-fat breakfast may delay its effects. Symptoms of Overdose. Symptoms of overdose include changes in heart rhythm and rate, hypertension, confusion, breathing difficulties, sweating, vomiting, and muscle twitches. If they occur, parents should call the doctor immediately. Even among young people who abuse Ritalin, however, less than 1% experience severe side effects (rapid heart rate, hypertension) and outcomes are generally good. (Side effects may very severe, however, if Ritalin is overused and taken with other drugs.) Long-Term Complications. Many people have taken Ritalin for years without experiencing adverse effects or loss of effectiveness. Few long-term complications have been reported, but the following warrant some caution or additional research:
Concerns for Abuse. Studies on both animals and humans suggest that that Ritalin lacks the properties that create addiction, particularly in doses used for treating ADHD. Although methylphenidates have properties similar to amphetamines, their drug levels rise very slowly in the brain at the oral doses given for ADHD. This slow rise prevents a so-called "high" and subsequent addiction to the drug. A major analysis in 2003, in fact, indicated that methylphenidate treatment may even protect young people with ADHD from abusing alcohol or other drugs. In such cases, methylphenidates may reduce the need to self-medicate ADHD symptoms using nicotine, alcohol, or illegal drugs. (Ritalin does not protect against substance abuse in young people with ADHD and conduct disorder, however.) Dependence has not been reported in children who have taken this drug for long periods in appropriate dosages. It should be noted, however, that crushing the pills and inhaling them nasally can provide a euphoric state. The primary danger for drug abuse from stimulants appears to occur in non-ADHD young people who purchase these drugs illegally. In one study, for instance, 16% of ADHD children reported pressure from their fellow students to sell or give them their medication. AdderallAdderall is central nervous system stimulant, or amphetamine. It combines four kinds of amphetamine salts. It is inexpensive and can be taken once or twice a day. (Adderall XR is designed to be taken once a day.) Adderall may also be effective for adults. In one major 2002 analysis of comparison studies, parents and doctors reported that Adderall was superior to standard Ritalin, but teachers found no superiority of one drug over the others. Side effects include stomach problems and mood changes, including sadness, anxiety, and irritability. A few reports of sudden unexplained death (SUD) in children taking Adderall and Adderall XR prompted Canada to stop advertising the XR version in early 2005. Most Adderall-related SUD cases have been documented in children with underlying heart problems, but some deaths were found in those without heart defects. The FDA is evaluating the data, but at the time this report was updated it had not yet reached a final conclusion concerning the drug’s safety. Patients with structural heart problems or high blood pressure should not use Adderall. Other Central Nervous System StimulantsPemoline (Cylert). Pemoline is a central nervous stimulant prescribed for children who do not respond to other drugs. However, there have been 13 reports of liver failure or death in patients taking the drug. In October 2005, the FDA concluded that "the overall risk of liver toxicity from pemoline outweighs the benefits of this drug." The rate of reported liver failure in patients taking Cylert is 10 to 25 times greater than that of the general population. The FDA recommends that doctors switch patients to another drug. The drug was withdrawn in Canada in 1999. Dextroamphetamine. Dextroamphetamine (Dexedrine) is similar to Ritalin. Although it is commonly believed that it is both less effective and less safe than Ritalin, there is no evidence of this, and one study reported a slightly better response with dextroamphetamine. Side effects are similar. The arguments against dextroamphetamine mainly rest on widespread abuse of this drug in earlier decades. Some experts believe it may be an useful alternative for people who do not respond to Ritalin. Non-Stimulant: AtomoxetineAtomoxetine (Strattera) was the first non-stimulant approved for ADHD in children and the first treatment approved for adult ADHD. The drug works by increasing levels of both norepinephrine and dopamine, which are generally lower than normal in ADHD. The most common side effect is decreased appetite. A few cases of atomoxetine-associated liver injury have been reported, and the FDA has warned physicians that the drug should be discontinued at the first signs of jaundice or liver problems. Long-term effects, such as any impact on growth, are still unknown. In 2005, the FDA warned that atomoxetine may cause suicidal thinking in children and adolescents, especially during the first few months of treatment. Parents should monitor children taking atomoxetine for any changes in mood or behavior, and immediately contact their doctor if changes occur. AntidepressantsSpecific antidepressants are proving to be helpful under certain conditions and some may be reasonable alternatives to psychostimulants for some people with ADHD. Designer Antidepressants. Bupropion (Wellbutrin), reboxetine (Edronax) and venlafaxine (Effexor) are unique antidepressants, sometimes referred to as designer antidepressants. Such drugs affect one or more neurotransmitters that are not targeted by older antidepressants. These drugs may be particularly helpful for treating patients with ADHD and accompanying disorders, including depression or conduct disorder. Most studies to date have focused on bupropion and have reported good results in both children and adults. Tricyclics. Antidepressants known as tricyclics, which include desipramine (Norpramin, Pertofrane), or imipramine (Janimine, Tofranil), have been prescribed for children who do not respond to stimulants or who have accompanying problems, such as tics, anxiety, or depression. Desipramine appears to have the best results of the tricyclics and may even help control impulsivity. Tricyclics can have distressing side effects however, including dry mouth, sleepiness, and constipation. They have mild effects on blood pressure and heart rate, but such effects do not appear to be harmful in people without existing heart disease. Reports of sudden death of a few children taking tricyclics, however, have caused alarm, although these occurrences are extremely rare and the role tricyclics may have played is not clear. Reports of delirium and increased heart rate have occurred in adolescents who take tricyclics and smoke marijuana. Careful monitoring is important. SSRIs. The antidepressant drugs known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), which include fluoxetine (Prozac), sertraline (Zoloft), citalopram (Celexa), and paroxetine (Paxil), are sometimes recommended for treating depression in ADHD patients with both conditions. They have little effect on ADHD and in fact they may increase the risk for impulsive behavior. The effects of long-term use of SSRIs in young people are not clear. Some SSRIs such as paroxetine (Paxil) have been linked to increased risk for suicidal thoughts and behavior in children and teenagers. Fluoxetine (Prozac) is currently the only SSRI approved for treating depression in children and adolescents. [For more information, see In-Depth Report #8: Depression]. Alpha-2 Agonists (Clonidine)Alpha-2 agonists stimulate the neurotransmitter norepinephrine, which appears to be important for concentration. They include clonidine (Catapres) and guanfacine (Tenex). They are used for Tourette's syndrome and may be beneficial when other drugs have failed for ADHD children with tics or those whose primary symptoms are severe impulsivity and aggression. These drugs have a number of side effects. (Guanfacine may have fewer than clonidine.) Sedation is the most common. A clonidine skin patch, which gradually releases the medication, helps reduce the sedative effect. Because clonidine slows the heart down, it can have adverse effects in some children. Going off too quickly or missing doses can cause rapid heartbeats and other symptoms that may lead to severe problems. Studies in general report that the drug is safe, including in combination with stimulants. Of concern, however, were reports of five deaths in children taking clonidine with other medications. Experts strongly recommend that no child be given this medication without a preliminary examination for heart problems, and no child with existing heart, kidney, or circulatory problems should take it. Other Medications Investigated for ADHDSelegiline. Selegiline (Eldepryl, Movergan, Zelepar), also known as deprenyl, metabolizes into compounds found in methamphetamine and blocks monoamine oxidase B (MAO-B), an enzyme that degrades dopamine. A well-conducted study in 2003 suggested that it may be as effective as Ritalin with fewer size effects. Selegiline can cause hypertension if combined with drugs that increase serotonin levels--such drugs include nearly every major antidepressant. Modafinil. Modafinil (Provigil) promotes wakefulness and is used to treat patients with narcolepsy. It is being investigated for adults and children with ADHD, but studies have been mixed on its benefits. Determining a Correct RegimenDoctors still have a difficult time predicting which medications will produce beneficial results, so treatment is individualized and performed on a trial and error basis, which requires close observation and cooperation between all participants. In developing an effective medication plan, the following steps may be helpful:
Medications in Older Children. As children enter adolescence, the social stigma associated with ADHD often makes them reluctant to continue drug treatment. If the drug has proven to be effective, it is very important to keep the young person on the regimen during this critical period. Medications for Adults. One report suggested that two-thirds of adults with ADHD may also be successfully treated with stimulants and psychotherapy. Certain antidepressants may also be effective treatments in adults. Combination Therapy. A 2002 study reported that children with ADHD are increasingly being treated with a combinations of psychostimulants and certain antidepressants (such as tricyclic antidepressants and bupropion), and psychostimulants plus clonidine. Experts warn that there is little evidence that such combinations add any benefits and their long-term safety is unknown. Nevertheless, combinations may be warranted in certain severe cases, such as in children who are also suffering from an accompanying emotional disorder, such as bipolar or anxiety disorder. Behavioral ManagementBehavioral techniques for managing the child with ADHD are not intuitive for most parents and teachers. To learn them, caregivers may need help from qualified health care professionals or from ADHD support groups. At first, the idea of changing the behavior of a highly energetic, obstinate child is daunting. It is futile and damaging to try to force an ADHD child to be like most children. It is possible, however, to limit destructive behavior and to instill a sense of self-worth that will help overcome negativity toward life, which is one of the great dangers of the disorder. Behavioral Techniques at HomeBringing up an ADHD child, like bringing up any child, is a process. No single point is ever reached where the parent can sit back and say, "That's it. My child is now OK, and I don't have to do anything more." The child's self worth will evolve with an increasing ability to step back and consider the consequences of an action and then to control that action before taking it. But this does not happen overnight. A growing ADHD child is different from other children in very specific ways and he or she presents challenges at every age. Setting Priorities for the Parent. Parents must first establish their own levels of tolerance. Some parents are easygoing and can accept a wide range of behaviors, while others cannot. To help a child achieve self-discipline requires empathy, patience, affection, energy, and toughness. Some tips to help the parent are as follows:
Establishing Consistent Rules for the Child. Parents must be as consistent as possible in their approach to the child, which should reward good behavior and discourage destructive behavior. Rules should be well defined but flexible enough to incorporate harmless idiosyncrasies. It is very important to understand that ADHD children have much more difficulty adapting to change than do children without the condition. (For example, the child should do homework every day but might choose to start it after a TV show or computer game.) Managing Aggression. Some useful tips for managing aggression include the following:
Establishing a Reward System. Children with ADHD respond particularly well to reward systems. One study reported that they performed equally well when encouraged either by a direct reward for a correct response or with the use of a system called response-cost. With this system, the child is given the reward first and allowed to keep it if their behavior remains appropriate. Some suggested tips for rewarding the ADHD child are as follows:
Improving Concentration and Attention. In one study, children were given training twice a week using visual and auditory tasks on two different levels of attention. Lower level attention included being able to focus and sustain attention over time, and higher attention involved the ability to allocate attention among tasks. At the end of the 18-week program, children with ADHD were able to perform as well as non-ADHD children. More research is needed to confirm these results. Research indicates that ADHD children perform significantly better when their interest is engaged. Parents should be on the lookout for activities that hold the child's concentration. Some options that may help an ADHD child to focus are as follows:
Management at SchoolEven if a parent is successful in managing the child at home, difficulties often arise at school. The ultimate goal for any educational process should be the happy and healthy social integration of the ADHD child with his or her peers. Preparing the Teacher. Although teachers can expect that at least one student in every classroom will have ADHD, there is currently little training that prepares them for managing these children. The teacher should be prepared for the certain behaviors in the ADHD child:
The Role of the Parent in the School Setting. The parent can help the child by talking to the teacher before the school year starts about their child's situation:
Special Education Programs. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) requires the school to identify and evaluate children who may need help and to provide special services. Of note, however, parents sometimes report pressure by the school to put their children on medication or force them into special classrooms without clear educational justification. The schools, in these cases, may be acting illegally. High-quality special education can be extremely helpful in improving learning and developing a child's sense of self worth. Many families, however, may not have appropriate programs available for them. Programs vary widely in their ability to provide quality education. Parents must be aware of certain limitations and problems with special education:
If, in fact, ADHD is as common as studies are indicating, the best approach may be to treat the syndrome as a variant of the norm and train teachers to manage these children within the context of a normal classroom. Special programs are also required under the Rehabilitation Act and by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) for students at institutions of higher learning. It is the student's responsibility, however, to inform the administration at their college or university that they need such services. Unfortunately, many college students are reluctant to do this, although such programs can provide important and beneficial assistance in improving their academic performance. Other TreatmentsDietary ApproachesA number of diets have been suggested for people with ADHD. Several well-conducted studies have failed to support dietary effects of sugar and food additives on behavior, except possibly in a very small percentage of children. Still various studies have reported behavioral improvement with diets that restrict possible allergens in the diet. Parents may want to discuss with their doctor implementing an elimination diet of certain foods or adding supplements that would not be harmful and that might help. Food Allergies. Evidence suggests that children with behavioral difficulties may be sensitive to certain chemicals in foods. Studies vary widely, however, on how many cases of ADHD may be associated with sensitivities or allergies to food chemicals or additives, with results ranging widely from 5 - 62%. Among the suspected additives and foods that parents and studies report as inciting behavioral changes are the following:
In one small study, 62% of children who were given only rice, turkey, pears, and lettuce to eat for two weeks experienced at least a 50% improvement in symptoms. Nevertheless, about a quarter of the children pulled out because they could not stick with diet or they became ill. Feingold Diet. The most well known diet for ADHD is the Feingold diet, a salicylate- and additive-free diet, which requires rigorous vigilance over a child's eating habits. This diet also prohibits aspirin, which contains salicylates. Some parents report great success with this diet, although it may be difficult to impose, particularly on an ADHD child. One study that reported its efficacy suggested that it might not provide enough nutritive value, although the diet provides a wide range of healthy foods to select from. It is certainly wise, in any case, to avoid food with artificial colors and flavors and to provide a healthy balance of fresh, natural foods. It should be noted that allergies themselves have been associated with a higher risk for behavioral problems. Children who respond to allergen-restrictive diets, then, may not have had true ADHD in the first place. Essential Fatty Acids. Omega-3 fatty acids, found in fatty fish and certain vegetable oils, are important for normal brain function and may have some benefits for people with ADHD. It is not clear if supplements of fatty acid compounds, such as docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and eicosapentaneoic acid (EPA), provide any advantages. A 2001 study of DHA alone reported no reduction in ADHD symptoms. Zinc. Zinc is important for the metabolism of certain neurotransmitters that play a role in ADHD, and deficiencies have been associated with some cases of ADHD. Long-term use of zinc, however, can cause anemia and other side effects in people without deficiencies and it has no effect on ADHD in these patients. In any case, testing for trace minerals, such as zinc, is not standard procedure when evaluating children suspected to have ADHD. Sugar. Although parents often blame sugar for causing children to become impulsive or hyperactive, a number of studies now strongly suggest that sugar plays no role in hyperactivity. One study reported, in fact, that ADHD children had fewer problems after a high-carbohydrate breakfast than after a high-protein one. Another reported that children actually moved more slowly after a high-sugar meal, suggesting the carbohydrates may have a sedative effect. (Still, it's probably always wise for any child to cut down on sugar.) Feedback ApproachesTechniques that use biologic or auditory feedback and proving to be effective tools for increasing children's attention--a primary factor in low academic performance. Neurofeedback. Neurofeedback is an approach that uses electronic devices to help the child control his or her own brain wave activity. Electrodes are pasted to the child's head and pick up signals from the brain. The child watches images, such as moving graphs, on a computer monitor that reflect the child's brain wave activity. Typically, children are then taught certain high-level mental activities at the point when feedback information on the screen indicates that they are fully concentrating. Typically children attend forty 50-minute sessions, usually twice a week. Small studies have reported significant improvement in inattention, impulsivity, and response time. In one study IQs increased by an average of 12 points and Ritalin use had dropped significantly at the end of training period. To date, however, studies have been very limited and the results could have been due to factors other than neurofeedback. It is also very expensive ($40 to $120 per session). More research, however, is certainly warranted. Interactive Metronome and Musical Therapy. Interactive metronome uses feedback from sound to improve attention, motor control, and certain academic skills. In this technique study, children wear headphones and sensors on their hands and feet. They perform a number of exercises to a rhythmic computer-beat. Training sessions are completed in three to five weeks. Some small studies have reported improvement in attention, motor control, language processing, and behavior. (In support of this, some parents report that learning a musical instrument helped their children significantly.) Other Alternative RemediesProcedures and Non-Drug Therapies. A number of alternative approaches may benefit children and adults with mild ADHD symptoms. For example, daily massage therapy helps ADHD adolescents feel happier, fidget less, be less hyperactive, and focus on tasks, according to a study published in 1998. Other alternative approaches that may be helpful include relaxation training, meditation, and music therapy. Natural Remedies. A number of parents resort to alternative remedies as an alternative to psychostimulants and other drugs. Small trials have found some herbs and supplements, such as oral flower essence, ginkgo biloba, panax ginseng, and melatonin may possibly have benefits for ADHD. Based on existing evidence, however, none can be recommended, particularly for children.
Resources
ReferencesBrown RT, Amler RW, Freeman WS, Perrin JM, Stein MT, Feldman HM, et al. Treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: overview of the evidence. Pediatrics. 2005;115(6):e749-e757. Escobar R, Soutullo CA, Hervas A, Gastaminza X, Polavieja P, Gilaberte I. Worse quality of life for children with newly diagnosed attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, compared with asthmatic and healthy children. Pediatrics. 2005;116(3):e364-e369. Research Units on Pediatric Psychopharmacology (RUPP) Autism Network. Randomized, controlled, crossover trial of methylphenidate in pervasive developmental disorders with hyperactivity. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2005;62:1266-1274. Wolraich ML, Wibbelsman CJ, Brown TE, Evans SW, Gotlieb EM, Knight JR, et al. Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder among adolescents: a review of the diagnosis, treatment, and clinical implications. Pediatrics. 2005;115(6):1734-1746.
Review Date:
12/7/2005 Reviewed By: Harvey Simon, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital. The information provided herein should not be used during any medical emergency or for the diagnosis or treatment of any medical condition. A licensed medical professional should be consulted for diagnosis and treatment of any and all medical conditions. Call 911 for all medical emergencies. Links to other sites are provided for information only -- they do not constitute endorsements of those other sites. © 1997-
A.D.A.M., Inc. Any duplication or distribution of the information contained herein is strictly prohibited. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
© Copyright HealthBasis 2006. All Rights Reserved. |